Score: 2

"TBO"

submission: Camp North is Dead

date: July 7, 2009

This could use a lot of improvement... I'm not a huge fan of colabs, but I'm a bit confused as to what was supposed to be appealing about this.

-I'm really not impressed with the art work, i've seen toddlers draw the like. +0
-For the most part, the animation ranged from extremely poor to non-existent. +0
-The music/sound design was interesting at some points. +2
-The concept for the project seemed to have very little thought or effort put into it. +0
-My general reaction to this is "why would you want to show me this?" +0

I understand that the premise of this project was supposed to be random, and I am no stranger to random humor -- however the best advice I can offer is to set a goal for the project (how do you want your audience to react?) and pass that concept along to your team.

Score: 9

"bizzar"

submission: cupcake?

date: July 2, 2009

i love the sureal art style, but i love cupcakes. But now i'm sure that if I eat another cupcake, ill always be wondering about which vegitable is it that it does.
I am interested in the videos you show me...

Score: 3

"what the..."

submission: The Shebeats Detective X

date: June 29, 2009

horrible song... the chorus is a bad rip off of a song by Jett, which is an aweful aweful band - and the rest of the song is like random filler.

the animation is decent, but the story and style does not match the song. The whole thing just clashes...

Score: 10

"word"

submission: GUN & SWORD

date: June 28, 2009

Trigun meets FF7.
Awesome fight scene

Score: 10

"Insane"

submission: Walk in the Woods

date: June 17, 2009

I like it.
I'll definitely ask the pilot on my next flight to mind out for stray rhinos.

Score: 7

"Go army!"

submission: Birthday 18

date: June 15, 2009

sounds like joining the army is exactly what you need.

Score: 2

"why?"

submission: A Random Day

date: June 14, 2009

yeah it's random... but you guys can't be serious, this is garbage. There's nothing appealing about this at all, bad art, bad animation, bad humor. It's quite obvious you didn't even try... I'm actually insulted by having wasted my time watching this.

Score: 7

"Room for improvement"

submission: Primal War 19

date: June 13, 2009

The story line seems alright... random dinosaurs vs. random mamals, and then there are some chicks that do fireworks.
Its not deep, but interesting enough. I haven't watched the first 18 episodes, however I think it's safe to say that there's way too much going on here, and I have no idea what most of it even means.

The drawings are alright, but the animation made me laugh. There's even a scene where nothing is moving but the chick's breasts. But the thing that bothered me the most is the sound effects. The un-intelligable growling seems to be re-used several times for multiple characters. During some parts, such as the last scene, you have action with 2 characters and captions on the bottom containing dialogue; this gives it very much of a comic book feel, and I think it's kind of cool that way... in my opinion, the growling kind of takes away from your video.

hope this helps.

Score: 8

"Nice concept"

submission: Did You Hear That?

date: June 12, 2009

it would have been a lot more interesting with fewer versions. Perhaps pick the best 3 next time?

Score: 9

"baccon"

submission: How the Swine Flu Started

date: May 24, 2009

Miss piggy's got a new VD